Transportation commission long needed
April 27, 2007
Alabama's transportation priorities don't really change every four
years, yet there has long been the prospect -- and often the reality
-- of significant changes every time a new governor is elected. That
unsound approach would end under legislation that passed the House
of Representatives this week.
For decades, the director of the state Department of
Transportation has been appointed by, and serves at the pleasure of,
the governor. Some governors have used the appointment as a form of
political muscle, holding out the big sums of road-building money
the department handles as enticements to get legislators who want
road work in their districts to vote with the administration.
Even when that hasn't been done, the periodic turnover in the
governor's office sometimes has led to ongoing construction projects
being altered or even halted with a change in administrations.
It's a poor way of handling the taxpayers' money and of setting
priorities for transportation policies and projects.
But under legislation offered by Rep. Cam Ward, R-Alabaster, and
backed by Gov. Bob Riley, the state would have a transportation
commission which would oversee the department and hire the director.
The commission members' staggered terms would extend beyond the
terms of governors, thus helping provide a degree of continuity that
hasn't always been present in the department's operations.
It makes a lot of sense. The bill, which sailed through the House
on an 89-10 vote, establishes a five-member commission appointed by
the governor. For purposes of the appointments, it divides the state
into southern, central and northern regions, with one appointment
from each region. Two appointments would be from the state at large,
with the provision that neither could reside in the same
congressional district as another member.
That assures broad representation, which is also mandated in
another provision which requires the membership to "reflect the
racial, gender, geographic, urban/rural and economic diversity of
the state."
No one could make a career on the commission, either. Members are
barred from serving consecutive terms.
Commission members may not hold any other public office. Further,
they are explicitly barred from being "employed in the roadbuilding
industry, as a lobbyist, or as an employee or member of a firm that
provides goods or services to the Department of Transportation."
Perhaps the most appealing feature of the bill is the staggered
terms of the members. The initial appointments would be for two,
three, four, five and six years, with all future appointments for
six years. Under that arrangement, every governor who follows Riley
would have some appointments during a four-year term, but not all of
them.
This is a vastly preferable system. The Senate should join the
House in passing this notable government reform.